Why
Women Make Better Leaders
The Gloria
Steinem Example
By Jaqueline Lapa Sussman
Women's Biz - January 2004
Many women believe that they have to act competitively and aggressively
at work in order to keep up with male colleagues who are socialized
from birth to be fierce, competitive, and ultra-focused do whatever
is needed to succeed. Working with men, they say, makes them try
to emulate male styles of leadership to be taken seriously and
in doing so, lose their natural looser style.
Into the prevailing wisdom than the word "feminine"
is to soft an image to lead came Gloria Steinem with her very
feminine style. She has attained power not by conforming to what
the social climate deems as powerful but by being caring, open
and adventurous. I had the privilege of getting to know her when
researching a book a few years ago on the inner psychological
reactions of leaders on authority. I conducted interactive Eidetic
Image Psychology experiments developed by Dr; Akhter Ahsen-the
leading theoretician in mental imagery, -with both men and women
in high positions in government and the corporate world. I probed
beyond their rational conscious mind to reveal their hidden, innermost
feelings, thoughts, and impulses, which is not the face we often
show the world.
In doing so, I discovered that the leadership styles of men and
women are very different. Although hardly average, Gloria Steinem
may be the test case to prove it. I gave her a simple command
to wave her hands in a criss-cross motion over a pin lying on
her coffee table and for three full minutes repeated instructions
not to grab it. She didn't, but later explained it was because
it did not feel like something she'd do though she wondered whether
others reacted the same way. "I didn't feel any reason to
grab it," she announced. Although it appeared that she was
obeying my commands, in fact the opposite was true. She was following
her own inner sense.
I next asked her to wave her hands but now directed her to grab
the pin in three minutes of exhortations which she did because
it felt "natural." Finally I repeated a double-negative
instruction: to not grab the pin or think of her childhood. Gloria
broke both commands, revealing herself to be a rule breaker. Most
men, on the other hand, follow those commands obediently.
Gloria recalled life as a wild child of six wandering around
in a raggedy bathing suit with uncombed hair catching minnows.
She felt excited and unselfconscious hunting for coins in the
dark and cold water off a pier amidst giant scary catfish with
long whiskers and other weird things. "It was adventurous
and mysterious there," she said and later connected a lifetime
of dreaming of finding objects or coins in sand or mud to this
origin.
I interpreted the coins as the wealth of potential she had deep
inside and the image of her courage to discover possibilities,
an independent spirit, a sense of adventure, openness and a love
of freedom and an ability to pursue the unknown or mystery of
things. In many ways, Gloria is symbolic of women - in the different
way she responded in the test compared to how men typically do.
Cutting to the chase of gender differences as evidenced by this
test:
1. Men often reveal violent, destructive states of mind: women
don't!
2. Females are at home with confusion and perplexity. Men cannot
tolerate it; which suggest women can endure ambiguity and stress
more easily than men.
3. Women can deny a felt emotion especially when those emotions
are unwelcome, revealing strategic ability to maneuver under difficult
circumstances. Men feel damaged when having to deny emotion.
4. Women become playful and use humor to effectively diffuse
a situation in which they are being controlled. Men become rigid
when feeling controlled.
5. Women cry to release tension then feel more strength. Men
find it difficult to cry or release tension, so they hold tight
and shatter more easily.
6. Women want to be real and true to themselves. Men don't consider
issues of being real. Winning is what matters. "When I demonstrated
to William Simon, the former Treasury Secretary of the United
States, how to wave his hands he counted the number of times I
waved my hands in order to figure out how to play the game to
win.
7. Mental and emotional insights are expressed frequently by
females, not the males.
8. The rules were broken most often by women. Men followed the
rules.
Men have tremendous pressure to perform in all areas of their
lives. They are rarely allowed to look vulnerable or needy and
must crush their sensitivities to look tough and in control. This
leaves them more rigid with fewer options to respond to throughout
their lives. Although women traditionally have not been allowed
power in our society, they have been freer to feel and be sensitive.
The connection to their inner sensibilities from which rich impulses,
thoughts and visions emerge, is more intact.
We need leaders who will break dysfunctional rules, bring truth
into situations and remain open to new visions. We need women
to be themselves, and as such, Gloria Steinem is a wonderful example.